Candle-Making for Beginners: Wax Types, Wicks, Fragrance & Coloring Explained

Ever bought a cute candle only to light it and think, “Why does this barely smell like anything?” Or tried making one yourself and ended up with a sad little wax blob that barely burns? Yep, I’ve been there—and that’s exactly why I’m about to spill the tea on how to make candles from scratch that smell like heaven, burn like a dream, and look like they belong on a fancy Instagram feed. No more sad, uneven flames or candles that barely throw any scent. From choosing the perfect wax to picking wicks that actually behave, measuring fragrance like a boss, and styling your jars to impress, this is your all-access backstage pass to candle-making greatness. Grab your materials, channel your inner candle maker, and let’s make some magic!

~~~

1. Choosing the Right Wax

Soy wax is my ride-or-die for every candle I make—and here’s why: it burns clean, holds fragrance like a champ, it is perfect for making whipped cream, and is eco-friendly. But hold up—candle lovers, there’s a whole wax universe out there, and knowing the vibes of each type will save you from a sad little wax blob disaster. 

Here are waxes that consistently perform well — whether you’re making everyday container candles, luxe scented jars, wax melts, or experimenting with styles.

I used to use Golden Brands 444 flakes from The Flaming Candle, and let me tell you—the quality was absolutely immaculate. Gorgeous finish, great scent throw… but that price? Let’s just say my wallet was crying in the corner. Enter American Freedom Soy Wax—my main go-to for all candles, including whipped/frosted styles. The quality is top-notch, burns clean, holds fragrance beautifully, and gives you the silkiest, most Instagram-worthy whipped cream effect.

Now, let’s talk about paraffin tablets for whipped candles… I once bought IGI 1239 A Paraffin Wax from CandleScience and oh. my. gosh. Total disaster. I’m talking sad, clumpy, unworkable wax blobs that refused to hold a peak and made me question my life choices. It was a hot, sticky mess that left me screaming. That said, this is solely my experience—other makers may have different results, and some even love it. It does work beautifully for crumb-style effects or decorative chunks, so don’t let my chaos scare you off entirely. Test small batches and see what works for you!

And for wax melts or molded designs, I stick to American Freedom Pillar Wax—perfect structure, clean release, and consistent results every single time.

~~~

2. Selecting Wicks for Even Burning

Your wax can smell amazing, look gorgeous, and promise hours of cozy vibes—but without the right wick, your candle can totally misbehave. Think uneven burn, tunneling, excessive smoke, or a flame that seems like it’s staging a rebellion. One of the most important things about a wick is its size: the bigger the wick, the larger the melt pool, which leads to a perfect, even pool and no tunneling. For bigger jars, make sure to upsize your wick and even consider adding 2–3 wicks, depending on the jar’s diameter, so your candle burns beautifully from edge to edge.

⚠️ Warning: Go too big with your wick, and you’re basically flirting with disaster. I’m talking flames that could singe eyebrows—or worse, burn your house down. Test, measure, and respect the power of a wick, people. Safety first!!

Cotton Wicks: The Reliable Classic

• Why I Love Them: Burns clean, predictable, and perfect for most soy candles.
• Best For: Container candles, whipped/frosted candles, and gift sets.
• Pro Tip: Match the cotton wick size to your container diameter. Too small? Your candle caves in. Too big? You get a fire that’s overdramatic.

Wooden Wicks: Crackle & Cozy Vibes

• Why Use Them: Adds a cozy crackle while burning and looks fancy.
• Best For: Luxury candles, gift sets, or when you want a show-stopping vibe.
• Pro Tip: Wooden wicks need careful sizing and a flat pour surface to avoid uneven burning. Test first—don’t just wing it.

Hemp or Eco-Friendly Wicks

• Why Use Them: Sustainable, clean burn, perfect for eco-conscious brands.
• Best For: Small-batch soy or beeswax candles with natural scents.
• Pro Tip: Often slower to burn than cotton, so check wick length and trim before lighting.

I currently use the eco-friendly cotton wicks from The Flaming Candle. I purchased their sampler pack with a bunch of different sizes and went full-on mad scientist testing mode. After trial and error, I found that size 14 or 16 wicks are perfect for my candle jars—burning evenly, creating a beautiful melt pool, and keeping that flame steady. By the way, there’s this thing called wick mushrooming — that little carbon buildup on top of the wick if it’s too long or the flame runs too high. It can mess with scent throw and create extra soot, but a quick trim keeps it under control.

I did try wooden wicks at first, and while I adored the cozy crackling sound (seriously, it’s like a campfire in a jar), they just didn’t play nice. No matter how careful I was, I could never cut them just right, and if the wick splits, the flame dies in seconds! I just didn’t have the patience. But man, that crackle sound? So worth it for the ambiance.

How to Choose the Right Size

1. Measure the diameter of your container.
2. Check manufacturer recommendations for that wax type. For example, American Freedom Soy Wax works well with medium cotton wicks for 3–4 inch jars.
3. Test, test, test! A wick might perform beautifully in a small jar but struggle in a larger one. For bigger jars, consider adding multiple wicks (2–3) to ensure an even melt pool and perfect burn.

Insider Tip:

Think of wicks as your candle’s personality. Pick the right one, and it’s a star. Pick the wrong one, and your candle could flop, tunnel, or throw a tantrum worthy of its own drama scene. If you pour a wide jar and use only one short wick, it won’t have the strength or height to melt all the wax. A tunnel will form, and as the wax rolls down, the wick will eventually drown — a tragic, avoidable fate. Properly sized and positioned wicks ensure an even melt and a candle that actually works.

~~~

3. Measuring Fragrance Oils for Perfect Scent

So your wax is dreamy, your wick is on point, but without the right fragrance load, your candle is basically a mood killer. Too little scent, and people won’t notice it. Too much, and your candle could smoke like a tiny chimney—or worse, not set properly. Let’s get this fragrance game strong.

What Is Fragrance Load?

Fragrance load is basically the percentage of fragrance oil to wax. Think of it like seasoning a cake—too little sugar, it’s bland; too much, and it’s a disaster. For soy candles like mine with American Freedom Soy Wax, I usually stick to 9% fragrance load. That gives a strong scent throw without making the wax behave badly. There are actual sites and tools that help you calculate the exact amount of fragrance and wax per vessel—like the West Sound Candle Supply calculator—so you can measure like a pro and avoid any waxy disasters.

Example: When I used the IGI 1239 A Paraffin Wax tablet for crumb-style effects (because I couldn't return it after the whipped cream disaster), I tried a 9% fragrance load. Once I did this, the wax started to sweat, and the oil literally poured out like water. Tuning it down to 6% solved the problem and kept the wax stable while still smelling amazing.

Pro Tip: Always check your wax manufacturer’s recommended fragrance load. Some soy blends can handle up to 12%, but pushing it too far can make your candle soft, greasy, or prone to tunneling.

Layering and Blending Scents

Want a candle that wows? Mix complementary fragrances: vanilla + cinnamon for cozy vibes or lavender + eucalyptus for a fresh, spa-like feel.

Also, be sure to add fragrance at the right temperature: too hot, it evaporates; too cold, it won’t bind to the wax. For most soy waxes, aim for 170–180°F (77–82°C) before pouring.

One of the biggest rookie errors is too much fragrance—it can make your candle smoke, sink, or burn unevenly. Nobody wants a candle having a meltdown on them. On the flip side, too little fragrance? Sure, it burns fine, but your candle will barely smell like anything. Meh. And then there’s adding fragrance at the wrong temperature: pour it into hot wax, and poof—it evaporates; add it to cold wax, and it won’t mix in properly. Precision is key, if you want your candles to actually wow instead of flop.

Pro Tip: Test small batches first. Your nose and your customers will thank you, and you’ll avoid any scent disasters.

~~~

4. Using Candle Dye for Colorful Creations

Okay, let’s talk color, because nothing elevates a candle from “cute” to “I need this on my shelf yesterday” like a pop of pigment. But coloring candles isn’t just about tossing in a pinch of dye and hoping for the best—there’s a little science, a little art, and a lot of fun involved.

Types of Candle Dye

• Liquid Dye: Super easy to use, dissolves right into your melted wax, and perfect for consistent color. Works well for both soy and paraffin wax.
• Powder Dye: Vibrant, concentrated, and perfect for deep, saturated colors, but it requires more precision—too much and your wax can get grainy.
• Chips/Blocks: Convenient for beginners. Toss in the recommended amount, stir, and watch the magic happen. Great for layering or creating ombre effects.

When it comes to adding color, candle dye goes in at the same temperature you add your fragrance, and trust me—stir for at least 2 minutes so everything melts and blends together perfectly. Some candle makers like to get fancy with mica powder, which gives a shiny, glittery effect once the wax melts—but beware: too much mica can block your scent throw.

Personally, I spent a whole year wrestling with liquid candle dye, and let me tell you, it was a nightmare. No matter how tightly I closed the bottles, the dye always spilled, my hands were constantly stained, and cleaning up was a total headache. On top of that, I kept running into color bleeding—my perfectly layered candles would turn into a sad, smudged rainbow. After lots of trial and error, I finally switched to candle chips a few weeks ago, and wow—no stained fingers, no bleeding colors, and perfectly blended layers every time. Honestly, it’s a game-changer.

Tips for Coloring Your Candles

1. Start Small: Add a little dye at a time. You can always add more, but you can’t take it out.
2. Match Wax Type: Some dyes work better in soy, others in paraffin, so check manufacturer instructions. 
3. Layering Colors: Want an ombre or swirl effect? Pour in layers, letting each set slightly before adding the next. It’s like painting, but edible-looking wax is your canvas.
4. Test First: Always try a small sample batch before going all-in. You’ll see how the color develops as it cools—colors often darken slightly after setting.

~~~

5. Choosing Candle Jars & Labels

Your wax, wicks, fragrance, and color are on point—but if your candle is sitting in a boring jar with a label that looks like it was drawn in 5 seconds, you’re missing the magic. Containers matter, and they can make or break your candle’s look, burn, and brand vibe.

Types of Candle Jars

• Glass Jars: The classic choice. Heat-resistant, easy to clean, and perfect for soy candles. Clear glass shows off your color layers beautifully.
• Tin Containers: Lightweight, travel-friendly, and great for gifting. Works best for smaller candles or solid wax melts.
• Ceramic or Decorative Containers: High-end look, perfect for premium or seasonal candles. Make sure they’re heat-safe!
• Fancy Glasses: Think martini glasses, Irish mugs, coffee mugs, or any quirky vessel that fits your vibe. These are perfect for gifts, themed collections, or Instagram-worthy candles. Just make sure they’re heat-resistant and safe for burning.

Size & Shape Matters

• Big jar = bigger wick (or multiple wicks!). Always match container size to wick and wax type.
• Short, wide jars burn differently than tall, narrow ones—test first to avoid uneven melt pools or tunneling disasters.

Labels & Branding

• Informative & Cute: Include fragrance, burn time, and any safety warnings.
• Aesthetic: Match your brand’s vibe and color palette. A well-designed label can make your candle “pop” on shelves or Instagram feeds.
• Tips: Waterproof or laminated labels survive heat, oils, and accidental wax drips better than paper ones.

Insider Tip:

A gorgeous candle in a boring container is like a runway model in sweatpants—cute, but not unforgettable. Put some thought into your jar, your label, and how it all works together. Your candle deserves to look as amazing as it smells.

~~~

6. Where to Buy Candle-Making Materials

• The Flaming Candle: Wax (soy, pillar, paraffin), eco-friendly cotton wicks, wax melts, and sampler packs for testing.
• CandleScience: Wax (soy, pillar, paraffin), fragrance oils, dyes, and bulk candle supplies.
• Amazon/Etsy/Specialty Stores: Glass jars, tin containers, ceramic pots, martini glasses, coffee mugs, and other fun containers.
• Label Suppliers: Waterproof or laminated labels to survive heat, oils, and accidental wax drips.

And there you have it—the ultimate guide to making candles that wow. From picking the perfect wax and wick, measuring fragrance like a pro, adding vibrant color without a mess, to choosing the right container and label—now you’ve got all the secrets to create candles that look gorgeous, smell incredible, and burn beautifully.

Remember, this is all my personal experience—there’s room to experiment, fail, and find your own favorites. Candle-making is part science, part art, and all fun. So grab your wax, your wicks, your dyes, and go make something amazing! 

Get Inspired

Thank you for reading! Yours truly, Chali from KC <3